Tag: John Wenlock-Smith

Review – Nicholas de Renty – Retour Au Bercail – by John Wenlock-Smith

Progressive music certainly has the ability to throw you some strange or odd musical curves, take this album from French solo musician Nicholas de Renty entitled ‘Retour Au Bercail’ which translates as meaning ‘Return to The Fold’ .

Nicholas performs the majority of the instruments apart from on the track Traquenard where he is joined by Anthony Malaussena who adds guitar and bass to the track, Nicholas playing drums, piano and the vocals, which are all sung in French. A lot of the other instruments are delivered via the computer, the brass and woodwind elements for example that enliven proceedings. This release is best heard in one setting, i feel, as you can then appreciate the intricacies that are built into the music especially in the title track Retour Au Bercail which has excellent brass and woodwind sections.

The album is basically the story of Nicholas’ return to the faith he grew up in but deserted in his youth. He now feels the need to address the spiritual emptiness he has been experiencing and sees a return as being in his best interests. This is bold for such a step to be considered and then taken and ultimately to be chronicled in the music he has made.

I had a translation of the lyrics so I could follow his journey, there is an understated beauty to this musician in his openness to embracing faith once again, which is to be applauded. This album will probably be passed over by many which is a shame as it is really rather good and interesting musically. I would say the singing is a little different and unusual but it is not unpleasant being strongly choral in style. I understand this might be off putting for many but I would urge you to persevere with it as it does become rather calming with a distinct spiritual tone and flavour to it.

I especially liked the opening track Luerre éternel (eternal war) which has a drum solo at both the opening section and at the 5.55 mark where Nicholas vocalises over the beat before a rippling piano and subdued brass are heard. Nicholas then really pounds the skins a for few minutes, oddly enough the dynamics of this work exceptionally well, giving the track a  really strong dynamism and emphasis. The lyrics are actually more prose, being almost poetic in nature and tone, the choir like chanting is a good fit for the track which is about how we are all in a spiritual war with the forces of evil (Satan and his demonic hordes).

As I say it is an intriguing and deep concept. One with it’s spiritual overtones and concept could, I accept, be problematic for some listeners and the album is maybe not an easy listen per se. However, many a great album is equally as challenging yet critically applauded like ‘Red’ by King Crimson, which is an equally dark and intense piece of work.

I have to say that the more I listen to this album the more I have come to appreciate it’s difference, which I feel is rare in a genre where little has changed since the founding fathers’ original masterpieces were released. This album at least dares to be different in many ways and that alone is worthy of recognition. As such, I would recommend that folks with an open mind would have a listen at least as there is some great music on display here,

Definitely one for the more adventurous listener to at least have a go with, although I would say it would be more appealing if the booklet had the words translated into English so then non-French speakers couldn’t least be more understanding of the contents of the words.

This has not been an easy review as it has required the input of Anne-Claire from Bad Dog Promotions to help with the translation, which then allowed insight into the themes behind the tracks, for which I must recognise her invaluable assistance. aAs it is but I urge perseverance with this most interesting release which I actually really enjoyed, hopefully others will too.

Released 27th August, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://nicolasderenty.bandcamp.com/album/retour-au-bercail

Review – Sharks: Car Crash Supergroup – The Island Years 1973-1974, 3CD Box Set – by John Wenlock-Smith

It almost seems that in the 1970’s you couldn’t move for supergroups, that strange scenario where bands split, only to re-emerge in a new combination of musicians. Some of these were very successful, like Emerson, Lake & Palmer, others less so, where the combination was just to volatile to exist peacefully enough to make their mark, like Beck, Bogart & Appice or Rough Diamond, for example. Punk might have brought the demise of many such groups but it didn’t kill them off completely, as bands like Asia can attest.

Sharks were one of those groups that should have been far bigger than they were, somehow they never quite made the grade despite having a very strong line up of Steve ‘Snips’ Parsons on vocals, Andy Fraser of Free on bass and Chris Spedding on guitar, along with Marty Simon on drums. Their debut album ‘First Water’ was released in 1973 on the Island label to much hype that unfortunately did not translate into many real sales.For the second album, ‘Jab It In Yore Eye’, Andy Fraser was replaced with Buster Cherry Jones. It was released in 1974 to a world that wasn’t very bothered. The band toured the USA to good audiences but, again, without more sales. Upon their return, they recorded a third album, ‘Car Crash Tapes’, produced by John Entwistle of the Who, but Island weren’t satisfied with the results and opted not to release it, this caused the band to split up and go their own ways. Spedding did some solo and Guitar Graffiti albums and he was also one of The Wombles, the one with the flying V guitar. Snip joined the Baker Gurvitz Army and Buster Cherry Jones returned to the US and started a new band with Donald and Ralph Kinsey called White Lightning, who released an album for Island records in 1975.

This set comprises of the first two releases, along with that third, unreleased, album ‘Car Crash Tapes’. It also includes live tracks recorded in Providence, Rhode Island in 1974, one of which features Leslie West of Mountain on Guitar. So that’s the back story but what’s the music like? Well, if like me, you were too young to remember them (I was 14 at the time), let’s have a listen through and I’ll tell you what I think.

The debut ‘Fresh Water’ emerged in 1973 after Fraser had left Free after their ‘Free At Last’ album of 1972, wasting little time in joining forces with Chris Spedding to form Sharks, who were signed to Island Records, with whom Fraser’s previous band Free had resided. Steve ‘Snips’ Parsons was spotted by Chris Blackwell and, after a successful audition, was offered the role of singer in Sharks, who Blackwell was managing at the time, having cut his teeth in the North East around the Hull and Humberside area.

The band travelled around in a customised PontiacLle Mans that they affectionately called The Shark Mobile, due to a fin on the roof and teeth on the grill which made an impact. A lot of their interesting history is detailed and recounted in the album booklet along with some great historical photographs of the band. They crashed the car into a tree in the north of England whilst on tour, with Andy Fraser injuring his arm. After this he though heavily about his options and decided to leave whilst he had the chance as he saw the crash as being a bad omen.

‘First Water’ is not a bad album in many respects, with a mixture of classic sounding rock and some sweet guitar work from Spedding. A lot of the tracks are slow burners, meaning that it takes time to really get into them fully, Follow Me being a prime example of this, with a strident piano from Fraser holding the song together and an ascending riff from Spedding that is fairly dramatic. I really like this track, it’s somewhat understated but could have been great live with its decent guitar break and fill section. Ol’ Jelly Roll has more piano and a initially delicate vocal from Snips which channels his inner Joe Cocker in the gritty vocals. This one has a touch of Free about it, especially in how it builds in intensity. Brown Eyed Boy is a Rolling Stones like romp with great dynamics to its swagger and Snakes And Swallowtails is another slow builder with Fraser’s bass at the forefront to good effect. I like this track with its understated playing that suggests the song is going to explode into something special, and it finally does, sounding tremendous, if not a bit short, when it could have been allowed to run on a lot more.

Drivin’ Sideways is more standard rock fare that doesn’t really go anywhere, despite good performances from Snips and Fraser and some almost countrified guitar fills from Spedding. But, despite its initial opening, I actually do like this track and it definitely grows on you. Steal Away sounds like a more mellow Free song, very subdued but actually rather good. Doctor Love is certainly of its time, especially in the lyrics. The track has a sinewy guitar line running through that sounds not unlike Paul Kossoff, which is a nice touch. The final song of the debut is Broke A Feeling, which is a fairly muscular sounding track with some good guitar fills which, along with the bass and the piano of Nick Judd, make a good sound. It’s all a little loose and all the better for that really. The mid section where Spedding lets rip is especially strong making for a strong finish to an album that had much promise that somehow the band were unable to capitalise on fully.

Sophomore album ‘Jab It In Yore Eye’ continues in a similar style and tone to the debut, although it seems a bit more focused somehow. The playing is more concise and impactful, it would seem that the departure of Fraser and the addition of Buster Cherry Jones was good for the band, allowing Snips’ songwriting abilities to be more widely seen, he writes or co writes seven of the album’s ten tracks. Baby Shine A Light is a great song with some excellent guitar work from Spedding, whose playing is subtle and yet exciting on this track. Sun Beat Down has a muscular sound to it, being quite a strident song yet somewhat understated and never actually exploding into life. It’s a bit of promise unfulfilled here despite some good guitar fills. Rain Or Shine is an acoustic song that lacks something, whereas Kung Fu is far better with its chopsticks type piano and some sweet guitar lines from Spedding which enliven proceedings. The Japanese words don’t really add much but Speeding’s playing in the mix does add some excitement to this track. Sophistication is next, a track in which The Clash were instrumental with their Should I Stay Or Should I Go track, you can see that in its stop start riff. Cocaine Blues follows and is a more restrained track. Revolution Of The Heart opens gently with acoustic guitar and then settles into  a more rock like groove. This is another slow burning track that gradually increases in its intensity to become something really fine over its six minute duration. With Chris Speeding’s understated guitar lines really hitting the mark, this track never explodes as such but the intensity and build both make a real impact.

The third album, ‘Car Crash Tapes’, is not as good as the first two and you can see why Island rejected it. The live tracks are taken from a  bootleg recording that have been cleaned up for this set. Again, these are of their time but are a nice addition to what is another fine set from the ever-reliable Cherry Red /Esoteric label and the booklet is of the usual very high standard.

In conclusion, this won’t be to everyone’s taste but it shows that some quality music was being made in the days before punk. How this band failed to achieve major success is one of Rock’s more tragic tales.

Released 24th January, 2025.

Order from Cherry Red here:

https://www.cherryred.co.uk/sharks-car-crash-supergroup-the-island-years-1973-1974-3cd-box-set

Review – Infringement – Black Science and White Lies – by John Wenlock-Smith

‘Black Science and White Lies’ is the third album from Infringement after ‘Alienism’ (2019) and ‘Transition’ (2017) The album follows a man’s journey through faith, his identity and, eventually, his redemption.

Infringement are Stig André Clason (guitar), Kristoffer Utby (drums), and Hans Andreas Brandal (vocals). Keyboardist Bård Thorstensen joined the band for their live performances and soon became a permanent member. Their latest addition, to complete the permanent line-up, is Emil Olsen on bass. Brandal has a somewhat theatrical style of singing that works well on this fine two track (in multiple parts) album of two pieces, White Lies and Black Science.

Together these two tracks comprise the entire 43-minute duration of the album, an unusual and somewhat intense sounding album that mixes narrative and some fiercely strident and hard-hitting music. I recommend that you have the CD booklet at hand so you can follow the narrative more easily, as it is can be a bit obscure otherwise. Even so, it’s not easy to follow what’s going on. I found it better to just go with the flow and listen to it as a complete piece of a journey. On White Lies, the acoustic guitar, keyboards and piano work very well ,acting as a counterpoint to the despair of the vocals, as does the guitar break at the end of the track that gives such great dynamics to the piece.

I actually find strong connections in this piece to the parable of the prodigal son, where a son leaves home and eventually realises he was better off at home. This theme is especially apparent White Lies pt. 3 – Apostasy which is backed with a very muscular beat and a thrust of energy and power. There is great use of the Hammond organ throughout this section with some sinewy snaking guitar lines and power chords giving the track its impetus and drive. The following section sees the return to the fold as it were as he seeks reconnection to his family. Again this is all very much theatrical in tone and actually works well like that.

After this we move to the second, five piece, suite of Black Science, which is slightly longer in length. This piece opens with good interplay between the organ and the rhythm section with powerful drums from Kristoffer Utby and strong parts from bassist Emil Olsen alongside Stig André Clason‘s subtle guitar playing. The sound is complex and constantly changing in both style and tempo, there is more than a whiff of both Gentle Giant and King Crimson in this track as it evolves steadily, the piano from Bård Thorstensen is really fine and offers a good balance to the intensity of the other sections of the track.

I will admit to not having a clue as to what this track is about, although it seems to be about a state of evolution. The organ is very prevalent during the Crimson Skies segment of the track as are the epic tones of Redemption, along with more fine guitar work from Stig André Clason, whose playing is never less than stellar, his last solo concluding the track and album in style.

‘Black Science and White Lies’ is a very interesting and somewhat intense listen, as it will demand much concentration in order to fully grasp the concepts it contains. It is worth the effort though as Infringement reward you with some excellent musical passages and performances with some great sections and playing. I really wouldn’t mind delving further into previous albums from the band to get a grip of what they are  all about.

The booklet for the album gives a lot more information and is a recommended aid to getting the best from the music of the album.

Released 19th September, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://infringement.bandcamp.com/album/black-science-and-white-lies

Review – Stackridge – Lost And Found – The Reunion Years 1999-2015 – by John Wenlock-Smith

I can’t believe that in all my years, although being aware of them, I had never actually listened to any music from Stackridge, the Bristol based unit whose merging together of folk, prog, music hall and vaudeville stylings had somehow completely passed me by. Unbelievable and definitely my loss. So. now I find myself rapidly playing catch up, trying to rectify that oversight, which is rewarding, if not a little futile, as Stackridge have ceased to be, well for the moment at least.

Stackridge’s history is well documented online and in the rather marvellous ‘On Track’ book by Alan Draper, which details that history album by album. It’s possibly a book that many would enjoy reading, digesting and learning all about this seldom mentioned and largely overlooked band.

This fine 4 CD set comprises the reunion albums, ‘Something For The Weekend’, the ‘Lemon’ mini album and the 2008 release ‘A Victory For Common Sense’. The set is completed by a reissue of ‘The Final Bow’, a double album recording of their final show from their home city of Bristol recorded in 2015. It also features additional bonus tracks such as the 2006 re-recording of Purple Spaceships Over Yatton, Seek and You Will Find and both songs from the rare ‘Dummies’ CD single.

Stackridge have a near 50-year history, although it is a broken, disjointed timeline with periods of several years’ inactivity between the late 1970’s and the 1990’s, after which they returned to an increased level of activity once again. This means that ‘The Final Bow’ element of this release is able to draw material from their earliest and also their latter day releases and this makes the set different to the earlier live set of ‘The Forbidden City’ from 2007, with which it shares at least 10 tracks. The addition of track from 2008’s ‘A Victory For Common Sense’ helps as several of those tracks really make an impression here. As do long term fan favourites like Syracuse the Elephant and Slark, along with Purple Spaceships Over Yatton and Do the Stanley Stanley Aviator Brass, that draws the show to a fitting, if not a little understated, finale.

What I do like, and I think will appeal to Big Big Train Passengers, is the presence of Claire Lindley who adds her violin, guitar, ukulele and voice to these recordings. They all sound wonderful and pastoral even, at various points within the albums, especially on the live tracks where her presence is keenly felt. I also like that they delve back deep into their history for versions of The Road To Venezuela and God Speed The Plough. Something About the Beatles really appeals, with its somewhat whimsical lyrics. It does remind me at times of a less manic incarnation of the Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band without the whirlwind of mischief that was Vivian Stanshall, Stackridge seem to share a similar musical DNA, which makes their eccentricity all the more rewarding. I really am enjoying discovering all this wonderful music many years later on.

Whilst casual listeners may not find this the best introduction to Stackridge, it does have the advantage of offering a handy bite-size introduction to the band through its latter-day recordings and the great ‘The Final Bow’ set. This is all encased in a great clamshell box with individual sleeves for the albums, although ‘A Victory For Common Sense’ gets a gatefold sleeve and ‘The Final Bow’ gets a different picture for each disc, along with picture labels of each cover. The booklet is perfunctory and actually is a little light on details, giving more of an overview of the band’s history, the pictures are good though, it must be said, I certainly found it to be a fine set one that I will definitely return to again I’m sure.

I recommend it highly and I can only comment on how much I’ve missed out on over the years of this band’s existence. Don’t be like me, investigate Stackridge for yourself, you may be as pleasantly surprised as I have been with their excellent musicianship and witty and interesting songs.

Released 27th September, 2024.

Order from Cherry Red here:

https://www.cherryred.co.uk/stackridge-lost-and-found-the-reunion-years-1999-2015-4cd-box-set

Review – The Round Window – Fram – by John Wenlock-Smith

One of the best things about last year for me was getting out to go to more gigs than usual, several of these being in quite distant places for me. These included a couple of Sunday afternoon shows in Camden, another was in Reading and yet another was in Colchester, where I was fortunate enough to witness the first ever live performance from Essex based The Round Window, who were supporting the ever impressive EBB in a show at the Three Wise Monkeys public house.

This was a very interesting trip for me as Colchester is nearly 200 miles and several trains from Cheshire! Nonetheless, it was a trip I felt compelled to make as I had been utterly smitten by their second album ‘Everywhere And Nowhere’ which editor Martin Hutchinson had reviewed and raved about on this very site.

Which bring us in a very meandering manner to this latest release from The Round Window, the EP ‘Fram’, which is not long enough for an album but certainly strong enough to be a stand alone release. It contains a mere three tracks, however, when the tracks are as imaginative and varied as these then you are getting some real quality music that works well as both an introduction to the band and also marks a moment in their development as the band move forward to being more active and present in the current progressive rock scene.

The three songs, The Silence, Fram and the epic sounding Hourglass are performed by the three Lock’s, Richard on vocals, Thomas on Keyboards and Jack on drums. They are very ably assisted by Robin Armstrong of Cosmagraf who adds some impressive guitar to Fram and bass on The Silence, along with Gareth Cole who adds his multi-faceted guitar tones to Hourglass. In Addition, Per Malmberg adds his guitar to The Silence. The EP is also produced by Robin Armstrong via his Gravity Dreams label.

This EP works extremely well in offering a concise snapshot of a band who have upped their game significantly with new material that draws on what they have done previously and yet have somehow managed to move several steps further on in terms of their overall confidence and also in their visibility in the current scene. What has helped in this is their constant self-examination of who they are and this EP distils their hopes and dreams into just three songs that offer another side to the band with thoughtful and intelligent themes delivered with style and grace.

First (and longest track) The Silence is a song written from the viewpoint of a soldier in the First World War who is remembering past seasonal festivities at home with his family, something he is hoping can happen once more when the madness is over. The song begins with a somewhat sombre and atmospheric soundscape  which is very cinematic in tone before a beat is picked up with bass and drums. A strong vocal from Richard commences with the soldier’s memories and his strong wish to be home. The song paints a wonderful picture of family life that has been interrupted by events, at which point the song changes into a darker mood. A guitar break follows before more sombre words are voiced and we can tell that things have altered somewhat for the soldier as he tells his sister that all is not as he had previously communicated. He did it to keep his hopes alive but now they have been dashed. The song ends with sounds of a family gathering and it is a very moving track all told.

Fram tells the story of Fridtjof Nansen, a Norwegian Explorer who sailed in the ship Fram on an unsuccessful expedition to the North Pole in 1894. Despite his failure, he was hailed as a hero on his return. The song explores his thoughts and feelings on his failure and the subsequent success of Roald Amundsen in 1911 in the very same vessel, Fram. This track is very introspective and resigned in tone, not victorious in any way and has some great and very fluid guitar lines woven throughout.

Hourglass is another somewhat introspective and inward-looking piece, although it concerns itself with looking into the future at the end of another year and hoping it will be a better one that lies ahead. It is a reflection on the passage of time as well and is another superbly composed and delivered piece of cinematic progressive music.

This is a very satisfying, impressive release from The Round Window and bodes well for their next album. I consider myself lucky enough to have caught their first show and hope to see them again soon.

Released 29th November, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://theroundwindow.bandcamp.com/album/fram

Review – Kite Parade – Disparity – by John Wenlock-Smith

I’ve had ‘Disparity’ for a while now and have only just begun to fully appreciate its subtle elegance and beauty. Andy Foster and Kite Parade have created a very modern progressive rock album of strong songs and observations of modern life.

The album begins with the track Fraternal Angels, which is very upbeat, starting out with synth soundscapes and piano before the vocals kick in with a surging drive. The song is very wide open in sound and is an excellent opener to all that is to follow afterwards. The mid section of the track is very interesting as it details the state of the world and it’s inequalities, 20% of the world having 80% of its wealth and resources. The brief Open Your Heart calls for a fair redistribution of the world’s food supplies and wealth and to be fairer to everyone. Is This All There Is ? features Christina Booth of Magenta who challenges us to do and to be more as there is more to life than what we see and experienceT he delivery of this great song is excellent. The World Is Mine is from the view of one who is in the top tier of wealth and is still not satisfied with everything,

Lynsey Ward of Exploring Birdsong is the vocalist for Broken, which has a delicate piano and some great synth sounds among its shuffling melody. The introduction of Andy Foster’s excellent saxophone solo really adds to the dynamics along with some great slide type guitar sounds towards the end. There are great dynamics between the rhythm section of Jimmy Pellagrosi (drums) and Marcin Palider (bass) with Andy laying down a great guitar line on top. This segues into Forgotten Youth, which has a chunky riff and sound to it. This is another up-tempo song with very interesting lyrics. Also worth mentioning is the terrific sound that the album possesses and that comes courtesy of Rob Aubrey, the sound being excellent and clear with great dynamics. It sounds really good to these ears, modern with a great drive and urgency when required. I also like how the songs flow into each other, creating a continuous sound cycle which captures the attention. The song has an excellent outro that is very impressive and imaginative. The use of textures and colouring make this song very grand sounding and my favourite thus far on what is a very majestic album.

Is There Hope? is a prelude to the epic Make It Beautiful which begins with thunderous bass from Marcin which sets a strident tone for the song. The track has a great refrain that is very memorable indeed. This is a great piece of music, very hopeful and optimistic in nature, which is no bad thing! It is a plea to restore beauty to an increasingly ugly world. Yes, it might be a bit hippyish and unrealistic but one can hope that beautiful actions can happen and bring the beauty back for everyone to appreciate. All this leads into the final track, Listen To The Angels, another optimistic and hopeful song. Andy Foster might be a dreamer but he wants a better world and hopes that it will happen and, in these troubled times in which we currently live, surely that’s not a bad way to be. I for one applaud his efforts and share his hopes for a fairer future.

‘Disparity’ is a really strong album with much to commend and has some brilliant performances. It bodes very well for the future of Kite Parade, let’s us hope that it’s not too long before we see them in action once again, as they are at the vanguard of a growing wave of melodic and worthy progressive rock music.

I highly recommend this tremendous album to you all. As for me, I am going back to check out their earlier albums, ‘The Way Home’ and ‘Retro’ as they passed me by, so the time is right for me to get acquainted with them.

Released 4th October, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://kiteparade.bandcamp.com/album/disparity

Review – Bill Bruford – The Best of Bill Bruford – The Winterfold & Summerfold Years – by John Wenlock-Smith

This is a 3 CD box set containing 35 tracks of Bill Bruford’s original music made for his own Winterfold (for his more electric driven music) and Summerfold (for his more acoustic and more improvised ideas) labels. This set is an expanded version of a set originally released in 2006 and long out of print and has been totally redesigned and reimagined for today with new artwork and sleeve notes and offering a concise overview of Bill’s career since 1977.

Unlike his earlier set, ‘Making A Song & Dance’ of 2022, this set only focuses on his own material, so nothing from Yes, U.K. or King Crimson. I feel this actually helps you recognise just how excellent Bill’s work over the past 40 years has been. The fact that Bill “retired” from music in 2009 to focus on more academic pursuits makes this collection all the more relevant now, with a semi return to activities with the Pete Roth Trio with whom he is currently active.

This collection covers those 42 years from his Bruford days through his collaborations with Patrick Moraz and Michiel Borstlap and covers 18 albums from which this set has been entirely re-designed by Bruford’s long-standing associate designer- photographer Dave McKean and overseen personally by Bill himself. The range of styles encompassed is significant from the more fusion driven sound of Bruford the band, the improvisation of Moraz and Bruford and Borstlap and Bruford to the free form jazz expression of the various incarnations of Earthworks. The list of contributors is lengthy and varied but, above it all, is the precise timekeeping of Bill Bruford holding everything together in a well ordered fashion.

Beginning with Bruford, the band Bill started after leaving U.K. in 1977, we get 4 tracks from ‘Feels Good To Me’, two apiece from ‘One Of A Kind’ and ‘Gradually Going Tornado’ and just one from ‘The Bruford Tapes’. For me, this particular period of Bill’s musical journey is one I was aware of but had not actually heard for myself. Obviously a situation I now need to rectify ASAP,  as are the albums made with Patrick Moraz, which also warrant further investigation.

So it is really the Earthworks era that this review will concentrate upon, an era that is all instrumental jazz, mainly propelled by Bill on acoustic rather than electric drums, although it did introduce the concept of chordal drums (A hybrid of half keyboard and half drums) which afforded Bill a new dimension in which to explore new rhythmic possibilities and sensibilities, which he does to stunning effect on both Pilgrim’s Way and Stromboli Kicks, which both feature this style of playing. Bill’s playing uses a random collage of micro percussion taken from 82 samples of little blocks, bells, finger samples and others all played live in the context of the track. This is certainly unusual and somehow sounds intriguing and very impressive. The sound is most definitely unusual but an effective marriage of both chordal and electronic drums.

We then have a couple of tracks from the David Torn produced ‘All Heaven Breaks Loose’, which features the processed sound of Iain Bellamy’s tenor horn. This was Earthworks really throwing away any rulebook and improvising freely and to fine effect. Again we hear Bill’s masterful stewardship and timekeeping even with free improvisation. Both Temple Of The Winds and Candles Still Flicker In Romania’s Dark benefit from this freedom. Nerve from ‘Stamping Ground’ follows and here we find Earthworks in full on improvisation mode again to fine effect. This is exciting and unrestrained stuff, albeit tempered with the tight controls of Bill’s timekeeping and vision. This is followed by the simply gorgeous acoustic beauty of two tracks from ‘If Summer Had It’s Ghosts’ in the form of the title track and Thistledown, both very gentle, quietly melodious and beautiful, another one to search out for myself I feel. The disc ends with 2 tracks from ‘Apart And Yet Again’ which saw the introduction of Earthworks mark II, which was more acoustically propelled with a new cast of musicians to push Bill’s envelope, as it were.

CD3 continues the Earthworks journey, apart from a few tracks from the collaboration with Dutch keyboardist Michiel Borstlap, in which the duo play completely spontaneously without any prearrangements. This makes for some very interesting music in which both musicians really listen to each other and respond accordingly. It is very exciting stuff as you hear their interactions play out, this would fool most people as there is no road map for where the music goes, it is all brilliantly intuitive. A sole track from ‘A Coat Of Many Colours’ sees Bill in connection with fellow drummer Chad Wackerman and Luis Conte on congas, focusing on the pitch of the various drums in a unique sounding track. The remaining tracks show Earthworks mostly in live performances from various different concerts

Above all this set accentuates the sheer brilliance and dedication to his craft that marks Bill Bruford to be a doctor of rhythm and rightfully so too as his work on these discs encompasses a huge array of both styles and settings. This is not always a straightforward listen as you need to get into the groove and begin to appreciate the subtleties on offer within these tracks but it is definitely worth it as there is very much to enjoy and appreciate herein.

Released 18th October, 2024.

Order from Cherry Red Records here:

https://www.cherryred.co.uk/bill-bruford-the-best-of-bill-bruford-the-winterfold-summerfold-years-3cd-box-set

Review – Cyan – The Guardians – by John Wenlock-Smith

The Cyan release, ‘The Guardians’, comprises a mere three tracks, namely The Guardians Of Your Destiny, a 26 minute epic that has been resurrected from Cyan’s reimagining of the original 1994 album, reworked and extended from its original 12 minute run time with new parts and solo’s from all and sundry, All Around The World, that was used as the Progaid single in 2005 and there’s also an instrumental entitled Cyan. Both the first two tracks were on the original album ‘Pictures From The Other Side’, however, due to excessive running length and so as not to distract from what they had already worked on and re-recorded, they were left off.

The whole EP lasts for approximately 38 minutes in all and, whilst not a full album, it certainly is a hefty slice of Cyan music to savour and enjoy. Once again, the band comprises of Robert Reed on keyboards, Dan Nelson on bass, Peter Jones on vocals and various wind instruments and the guitar work comes from Luke Machin who never fails to impress with his fleet fingered flights of delight. They are also joined by the angelic voice of Angharad Brinn, whose ethereal vocals are highly impressive sounding and work well in tandem with Peter Jones.

The EP starts with the epic The Guardians Of Your Destiny. This begins with Angharad’s voice soaring over a wash of keyboard sounds and some muted percussion before Luke Machin lets fly with a soaring guitar line which is then superseded by Rob’s organ sounds. Luke takes over once again before Peter Jones sings the opening verse. As an opening section this is pretty epic with lots happening and it all sounds wonderful too. This leads to delicate short acoustic guitar section before Rob allows his keyboards free rein in an explosive set of runs. There is then a part with dual vocals from Peter and Angharad that shows the beauty of their two voices. A brief but soaring guitar solo from Luke intercedes before we return to more duo vocals and acoustic guitar interludes, along with a glorious synth solo from Rob and guitar break from Luke.

Rob’s organ sounds return before Angharad sings the refrain We Are The Mighty Ones that occurs at several points during the song, acting as a way marker in moving the song along and holding the sections together as one complete piece. The sounds are very Genesis like in tone and I feel it gives a point of reference in Rob’s musical development and plays as a tribute to the mastery of Tony Banks. The song draws towards it conclusion with another Luke Machin solo and more keyboard solo’s from Rob. Mention must also be made of the stellar Bass work from Dan Nelson who is there at every turn adding depth and Solidity. The track ends in a triumphant burst of impassioned vocals from Peter Jones before a return to the chorus of We Are The Mighty Ones and a final guitar fill from Luke.

All Around The World is a pretty straightforward listen that has more epic guitar from Luke Machin, who never fails to impress with his fluid playing. I’ve known Luke for over 15 years and have seen his confidence and abilities grow over that time and he always plays what is needed at the time. He is one of prog’s most versatile players, as his soon to be released solo album will invariably attest. The song then enters a longer keyboard part to finish. This excellent EP finishes with he instrumental track Cyan, which is really 2 instrumentals they used to play in the 1980’s that have been fused together with a few new parts added. This gives room for all to take their turn in the spotlight with Luke, Rob and Peter all taking the spotlight, Peter by means of his saxophone, Luke with his guitar and Rob embellishing everything with his sensitive and keen keyboard solos, sounds and textures.

Whilst this may be a shorter EP, it certainly is not without its merits and is a joy to hear these musicians cutting loose as they do in Cyan. ‘The Guardians’ is an excellent addition to the Cyan canon and will fit well alongside ‘Pictures From The Other Side’ to complete the full picture that album represents.

Released 16th August, 2024.

Order the CD here:

https://www.tigermothshop.co.uk/store/Cyan-The-Guardians-CD-pre-order-p674509462

Review – The Windmill – Mindscapes – by John Wenlock-Smith

If, like me, you enjoy symphonic prog, then you will find much to enjoy in this shorter album from Norway’s The Windmill. With definite touches and traces of Wish You Were Here in the long first track Fear, ‘Mindscapes’ has as good an opening segment as I’ve heard on many an album. This release also contains three shorter tracks, all of which show a different facet of the band

The vocalist Erik Borgen has a wonderful, if somewhat unusual voice, it reminds me in places of Roine Stolt of The Flower Kings. Also memorable here is the saxophone of Morton L. Clason which adds something of great depth to all the keyboards and clout of the rest of the band. Fear has a great soundscape and some dynamic passages, along with a great organ solo. It’s also, despite being nearly twenty-three minutes in length, a very endearing track with lots happening during its duration. In fact, the more I’ve heard it the better it gets for me, as it reveals deeper, hidden complexities which, when all taken together, forms a most impressive piece. The song  is in three distinct sections, Fear, Back Against The Wall and Amnesia, the middle section has a great urgency and wonderful interplay between the flute and the rest of the band, it also benefits from a strong chorus and refrain.

I really like this track, it has grown on me considerably as I have become more familiar with it. A good guitar break helps move the track along before an extended keyboard solo is introduced to the proceedings. Thereafter a flute solo plays as the songs moves into its second section and this is a well orchestrated part with good keyboards and more flute stylings, all of which add to the overall feel and impression the track is seeking to create. And create it well it does too, as this song really does make a favourable impression and impact.

Calton Hill is a tribute to the band’s good friend Brian McNeil who was based in, or certainly very well acquainted with, the city of Edinburgh. The song is about walking around the city and the delights of Calton Hill which offers a good view of the city and is adorned with monuments and is a very pleasant area to explore. I know, I did it over 30 years ago and long to revisit once again. The shorter  and more delicate sounding I Still Care seems to be about a loved one who is not around any more but, even so, he still cares about her. It’s a wistful rather than cloying song, it is very tender and heartfelt though. The final track Nothing In Return is a bit of a different beast though, as it has a heavier sound with a degree of crunching guitar, almost like Grunge Prog! The presence of the flute is clearly heard and felt and this actually really works with this song because the contrast with the guitar is distinct and the flute brings a degree of lightness to proceedings. A wild synth solo is played with increasing urgency and power which makes an definite impact. The track then heads out in a romping/rollicking section, all synths and guitar riffs in tandem and unison. The impressively solid bass of Arnfinn Isaksen is felt here and his weight adds much to the dynamics at play here. This song may be brief but it is certainly powerful and impactful.

‘Mindscapes’ may be relatively short for an album of this genre but it is definitely a triumphant one for The Windmill, coming six years after their ‘Tribus’ release of 2018 and shows this fine Norwegian outfit have much to offer still. I heartily recommend this for its versatile musicianship and its complex layers and soundscapes, it’s a very enjoyable listen indeed.

Released 1st July, 2024.

Order from bandcamp here:

https://thewindmillnorway.bandcamp.com/album/mindscapes

Review – Rick Wakeman – Yessonata – by John Wenlock-Smith

Rick Wakeman will, I’m sure, be known to many of you as he was the keyboard player during the golden era of Yes in the 1970’s, where his talents added significant input to the albums ‘Fragile’, ‘Close To The Edge’ and ‘Tales From Topographic Oceans’ before leaving the group and rejoining for ‘Going For The One’ and ‘Tormato’ after Patrick Moraz had left the band, in part due to the “enormous psychological pressures within the group”.

‘Yessonata’ is the much requested Yes highlights segment of his two shows at the London Palladium in 2023, where he performed his early solo albums in full on the first night. The second evening was a set of classic Yes material along with a performance of ‘Journey To The Centre Of The Earth’. `In among all this was a newly composed ‘Yes Suite’ in three parts, The Meeting, Wondrous Stories and South Side Of The Sky. Also included were versions of Roundabout, And You And I and Starship Trooper /Wurm. This was very warmly received, so much so that fans started to ask where they could get this, other than the 4CD live album where it was included on disc 3. This showed Rick that there was a demand for a recording of that to be made available so, in 2024, Rick set about  pulling the three parts together, adding a few more bits and creating his own Yes Sonata, hence the album title.

This new release was a bit too short so Rick also produced a piano variation of the ‘The Myths and Legends of King Arthur…’ album and is entitled The King Arthur Piano Suite. This album, whilst short, is excellently conceived, produced and delivered by Rick using a sole Steinway Model D Concert Grand Piano.

The music is truly sensational but the real fun is in recognising which pieces Rick is playing from which albums. The press release cites ‘more than 30 musical fragments’ but I don’t know the Yes back catalogue that well to recognise them all. Google search would give more insights but for me just hearing Rick perform this piece of work at his age is remarkable, as he still has great dexterity and ability.  I grew up as a teenager being introduced to Rick’s music through my brother’s friend who had ‘The Six Wives of Henry VIII’ album and my brother’s copy of ‘Yessongs’, which included Rick’s brilliant solo parts. I was totally mesmerised by his skills, this was further enhanced by a live Rick Wakeman DVD that I acquired in the 2000’s which included his hilarious Nursery Rhyme Concerto which is brilliant, extremely funny and superbly delivered. Rick is not only a classically trained pianist but also a fine raconteur with his off kilter sense of humour being well known to all.

A clip of that concerto is here:

In this piece Rick shows his tremendous talents, dismissing it as a simple little thing before then firing off a staggering piano motif or run that repeats throughout the track.

That same skill is on offer on this album of two tracks, ingenuity coupled with complexity and a confident delivery. It’s actually a rather fine collection of piano motifs compiled together to create a concerto that does as it says, it conveys the melodic sensibilities of the Yes canon in one single piano interpretation. It is an easy listen but also offers the listener the challenge of identifying the particular melodies that are so eloquently delivered. The King Arthur Piano Suite is similar in style and concept, again this is impeccably performed and distils the essence of the near 40 minute album to a mere 20 minute piano improvisation whilst still maintaining the feel of the original album.

The cover art from Roger Dean is equally as impressive and conveys the Yes connection through the images. With a sound that is clear and crisp, all in all this is a highly impressive concept and a unique album in which you can appreciate the music of Yes in a unique and possibly simpler manner than the albums.

Released 8th November, 2024

Order from Cherry Red Records here:

https://www.cherryred.co.uk/rick-wakeman-yessonata-cd-edition